GUBMENTPlain talk · policy frontier
Filings / Disability / Sources / GBMT-12 workstream source register (§1
GBMT-12 · Research record · No. 12

GBMT-12 workstream source register (§1–§8)

disability/research/ws-source-register.md
This is a working research document from the disability filing, published as written — including the parts later corrected. It is the underlying record for Whitepaper No. 12, not a summary of it.

As of: 2026-08-11. Continues Phase 0 register IDs (S1–S19). New IDs begin at W1. Advocacy and secondary compilations are labeled.

ID Source Type / vintage What it establishes Limits
W1 Liebman, Understanding the Increase in DI Benefit Receipt, JEP 29(2) 2015 Peer-reviewed decomposition Post-early-1990s: aging + women’s insured ≈ of DI-receipt rise; male adjusted incidence flat; 1980s incidence/policy swing separate Not a single 1980s–2010s pooled %; DI focus
W2 SSA, Trends in SSDI (bp2019-01) Agency briefing paper Summarizes OCACT gross vs age-sex-adjusted incidence; Pattison/Waldron insured-rate split; points to Liebman / Daly et al. Secondary synthesis of primary series
W3 SSA OACT, 2025 Trustees Fig. V.C3 plot points Trustees data table Age-sex-adjusted incidence 6.4 (2010) → 4.0 (2019) → 2.9 (2022–23) → 3.3 (2024) Incidence ≠ prevalence
W4 Liu & Quinby / CRR, Why Did DI Rolls Drop 2015–2019? IB 23-18 Independent brief 2010–19 incidence drop: business cycle −0.14 pp; residual ALJ/stringency −0.12 pp; aging +0.02 pp Residual attributed to ALJ policy by leftover, not RCT
W5 Duggan growth chapter PDF (Wharton) Academic chapter ~2005 window Larger shares to replacement rates / medical criteria for 1984–2003 Earlier window; conflicts with Liebman shares for that era
W6 SSA ODSSI, FY2024 Workload Data: Disability Decisions Agency workload Stage allows; AC remand 16%; federal court remand 63% of 15,753 Decision-year, not filing cohort
W7 GAO-18-37, Hearings accuracy/consistency GAO statistical model, FY2007–2015 Post-controls ALJ allowance range up to 46 pp; office range ~19 pp; −5 pp narrowing Vintage ends FY2015
W8 SSA, A04 AC remands / all AC RR dispositions Public appeals data FY2024 AC remand 18.05% (13,330 / 73,834) All AC RR, not disability-only
W9 SSA, A06 Court remands vs new court cases Public appeals data Court remand receipts FY2023 10,467; FY2024 10,030 Not matched to same-year filings
W10 SSA OIG, Major Management Challenges FY2024 IG Hearing APT 450→342; pending ~322k→~262k; initial APT 218→231 Management-challenges framing
W11 SSA, FY2024 AFR — Other Reporting Requirements AFR Payment Integrity SSI IP 10.62%; OASDI ~0.30%; cause %; stewardship = nonmedical; CDR ≠ original error Not intentional-fraud rate
W12 SSA, CDI Expansion Progress Report 2022 Agency BBA report FY2021 CDI 74 judicial actions; projected savings figures Judicial actions ≠ all fraud; savings are projections
W13 SSA BBA §845(a) FY2020 program-integrity narrative (AFR materials) Agency FY2020 CDI 1,729 cessations/denials; 77 judicial actions Single-year snapshot
W14 Anderson et al. / CRR WP 2022-11 Mathematica–SSA grant paper FY2019 disabled-worker FMRs 215,720; mailers 766,913; initial cessations+FTC 39,056 Cites SSA; not the open-data CSV itself
W15 SSA OIG A-01-21-51038 (DDS COVID workload) OIG audit Pre-COVID comparison: 136,481 DDS CDR cessations Period labels in audit tables; not a fraud count
W16 SSA OIG Spring 2026 SAR IG SAR Half-year: 221 convictions + 7 diversions (all OI categories) Not disability-only; not matched to IP $
W17 SSA, Red Book — SSDI employment supports / What's New 2024 Agency rules handbook TWP / EPE / extended Medicare (≥93 mo); 2024 SGA 1, 550 * *non − blind; TWPservicemonth * *1,110 Parameters index annually
W18 SSA, SSI ASR 2023 §7 — recipients who work / 1619 Federal statistical report 1619(b) 18–64 108,825 = 2.6% of blind/disabled 18–64 Continuance ≠ employment rate
W19 Abt/Mathematica, BOND FER Vol. 1 (2018); Abt Removing the Cash Cliff brief SSA-commissioned RCT/demo Offset: null mean earnings; Stage 1 benefits +143 * */yr; Stage2 * *+450–500/yr; EWIC null Demo ≠ current national policy
W20 Gettens et al., Evaluation of WA Medicaid Buy-In (JDPS 2012) Matched state evaluation MBI associated with higher work/earnings vs matched conventional Medicaid Single-state
W21 Gimm et al., Mathematica “three E’s” MBI 2006; Liu & Weathers earnings notes SSA/CMS-era MBI outcome series ~40% of wage-earning MBI participants increased earnings post-enrollment Pre/post among enrollees; selection
W22 BPC, Improving the Medicaid Buy-In (2022) Policy brief Last comprehensive national MBI enrollment ~193k (2011); data gap since Stale headcount
W23 SSA, Effects of TTW… Outcomes vs Design, SSB v83n1 Agency synthesis of Mathematica eval ITT STW effects null/not robust; service enrollment ↑; participant≠population Not a single pp employment cell
W24 Wittenburg et al., Initial TTW impacts, JVR 27 (2007) Peer-reviewed extract of Mathematica Service enrollment +0.1 to +0.4pp; no compelling earnings/benefit impacts (first 2 yrs) Early rollout window
W25 Mamun & Page / Stapleton–Mamun–Page TTW impact studies (2013–14) Mathematica / IZA Service enrollment ↑; no consistent months-without-benefits impact; STW power ≪2pp absolute Young new awardees / phase designs
W26 SSA, SSI ASR 2023 — children under 18 Federal statistical report Under-18 recipients 983,169 (Dec 2023) Point-in-time
W27 CRS R49011, PRWORA at 30: SSI for Children CRS PRWORA child standard; caseload arc 1996–2024; Zebley context Secondary to statute/ASR
W28 GAO-12-497, Children’s SSI benefits GAO ~54% denial of child mental claims; school-evidence gaps; childhood CDR collapse Window FY2000–2011
W29 SSA SSB v84n4, child SSI CDRs and participation Agency research CDRs explain ~⅔ of 2014–2021 child caseload decline in simulations Simulation, not RCT
W30 NAS / Urban Institute disability decision-process syntheses (eventual-allowance flows) Research synthesis Hearing allowances = appeals of prior denials; large share of appealed claims eventually allowed Not a new DRF extract
W31 CRS R41289; SSA EN-64-125 CRS / agency fact sheet VA VASRD 0–100% partial ratings vs SSDI binary SGA VA ≠ transferable cash architecture
W32 CBPP Dutch DI blueprint; SSA SSB v86n1 (Dutch WIA methods) Policy / agency journal NL partial benefits + 2-year employer sickness + experience rating Financing preconditions mandatory
W33 UK NAO/DWP ESA–PIP / WCA reassessment record (cautionary) Foreign admin / audit lineage Reassessment turbulence; tribunal overturns; process unfit critiques Transferability = caution, not model
W34 SSA OIG, Nearly $72B improperly paid FY2015–22 (2024-08-19) IG release Cumulative improper payments ~$72B; <1% of benefits Not a fraud total — citogenesis root
W35 Poynter, Musk/WH Social Security fraud claims (2025) Fact-check Documents $70B+ fraud relabel of OIG improper-payment figure Secondary to W34
W36 SSI ASR 2023 Table 37 — recipients with representative payee by diagnosis Federal statistical report Payee rates by mental diagnosis (heterogeneous); under-18 ≈99.9% Stock, not awards
W37 Klee et al., rep-payee health outcomes systematic review (Psychiatr Serv) Peer-reviewed review citing SSA Of ~1.7M disability beneficiaries with payees, 77.5% mental disorders Cites SSA; vintage ~2017 counts
W38 BPC Disability Insurance Working Group package (2015 window) Bipartisan policy package Solvency-as-vehicle for DI reform; offset + buy-in proposals competed with reallocation fights Political-economy, not RCT

Negative / opacity notes

Question Result
Intentional-fraud rate at SSI 10% / circulating magnitude Not found in AFR stewardship tables → KC1 / H3
Same-year paired CDR cessation vs CDI prosecution extract Direction clear; exact paired FY table still polish-owed (CSV access-denied this pass)
Post-2015 GAO-style ALJ case-mix re-estimate Not located; H2 rests on GAO-18-37 + continuing outlier audits
Current national Medicaid buy-in enrollment Stale (2011 ~193k last comprehensive) — O4 gap flagged, KC3 still clear via 1619(b)
Ticket ITT employment effect ≥2pp Not found → H5 supported
Mental disorders ≥25% of disabled-worker awards Fails at 12.7% → H8 deviation (stock/SSI legs)
$72B Social Security “fraud” as independent measurement Citogenesis — OIG improper-payment cumulative relabeled (W34→W35)
← All Disability research documents Sources digest Read the whitepaper